The Future I Thought I’d Have: Understanding Reproductive Grief

Before I learned the term reproductive story, I did not realize I had been writing mine for most of my life. I imagine many of us have been doing the same. Long before we are asked whether we want children, and long before words like fertility, pregnancy, or parenthood carry any real weight, we begin imagining what our reproductive futures might look like. We picture the families we might build, the kind of parents we might become, the names we might give our children, and the lives we assume will be waiting for us when we are ready. Yet some of the most powerful parts of these stories are not the things we consciously dream about, but the things we never think to question: that our bodies will cooperate, that pregnancy will be possible, that we will have enough time, and that when the moment comes, the choice will ultimately be ours. These assumptions can become so deeply woven into our identities and the futures we imagine that we hardly recognize them as assumptions at all. Sometimes, we do not realize how much of ourselves we have placed into a future until that future is no longer guaranteed. And when the future we had already made room for begins to slip away, reproductive grief can enter the space it leaves behind.

Jaffe, Diamond, and Diamond (2005) coined the term reproductive story to describe the conscious and unconscious narratives we carry about children, parenthood, and our reproductive lives. But these stories do not suddenly begin when we decide whether or not to have children. In many ways, they begin when we are children ourselves. Before we ever imagine becoming parents, we first learn what it means to be parented. We absorb ideas about love, caregiving, family, safety, sacrifice, and belonging from the people and systems around us. Some of us grow up wanting to recreate pieces of the families that raised us. Others quietly promise themselves that if they ever become parents, they will do things differently. We imagine giving our future children what we received, or perhaps what we needed and never had. Our reproductive stories carry pieces of our families, cultures, identities, relationships, values, childhoods, and hopes for whom we might someday become.

This is why a reproductive story is about so much more than whether or not someone wants children. We are imagining who we will be, who we will love, what our homes will feel like, which traditions we will carry forward, and which parts of our own childhoods we hope to rewrite. We imagine the child at the dinner table, the name carried through generations, the person beside us stepping into parenthood, and ourselves becoming the parent we once imagined we would be. Without realizing it, we begin making room for people who do not exist yet, building identities around roles we have not occupied and becoming attached to moments we have never lived. These futures can feel so deeply ours that we forget they were never promised to us. And when they become uncertain, we may realize we are grieving far more than an outcome. We may be grieving the person we thought we would become, the life we had already made room for, and a future we had begun loving before we ever had the chance to live it.

I used to think grief required something definitive. There had to be something you could point to and say, This is what I lost. Someone had been here and now they were gone. Something had existed and now it did not. There was a before and an after. Reproductive grief taught me that loss does not always work that way. Sometimes, nothing is definitively gone.

Sometimes, you are sitting in a doctor's office being told that the future may look different than you thought. Sometimes, you are staring at another negative pregnancy test or grieving a pregnancy that ended before the rest of the world even knew it existed. You may find yourself sitting in a fertility clinic discussing options you never imagined needing or having conversations about your body that you never expected to have. Sometimes, you are choosing not to become a parent right now, even when parenthood is something you have always wanted, because knowing the timing is not right does not make the grief weigh any less.

Perhaps that is one of the hardest things about reproductive grief to explain: grief does not always mean that hope is gone. Sometimes there is still possibility. Sometimes there are still choices. Sometimes you know you are making the best decision you can with the life, body, and circumstances you have. You can know all of that and still grieve what you wish had been different.

This is a contradiction I have come to understand personally: hope and grief can exist in the same place. We can feel grateful for the options that remain while mourning the fact that those options became necessary. We can hold hope for what is still possible while grieving the certainty we once had about how we would get there. Becoming a parent may still be possible, and yet the journey toward parenthood may no longer resemble the one we always imagined.

Sometimes, then, reproductive grief is not about losing possibility at all. It is about losing certainty. It is grieving the body you once trusted without thinking about it, the spontaneity you once took for granted, or the time you thought you had. It is grieving the ability to make reproductive decisions when you were ready rather than when biology, medicine, or circumstances required you to. It may be the pregnancy you imagined, the number of children you once pictured around your table, the age at which you thought you would become a parent, or simply the version of yourself who never knew any of this would be difficult.

There is a particular loneliness in this kind of grief because it can be difficult for others to recognize what has actually been lost. People may remind you that you still have options. They may tell you there is still time, encourage you to stay positive, or point toward the next treatment, the next possibility, or the next thing you can try. Often, they mean well. But reassurance can unintentionally leave someone feeling as though their grief is unwarranted simply because hope still exists.

Having options does not mean nothing has been lost. Being able to try again does not erase what happened the first time. Having embryos or eggs frozen does not erase the circumstances that made fertility preservation necessary. Becoming pregnant after infertility does not erase the months or years spent wondering whether pregnancy would ever happen. And building a family through a path you ultimately cherish does not require you to pretend that you never grieved the path you originally thought you would take.

Hope and grief are not opposites. There can be enormous gratitude for what is still possible and enormous sadness for what has changed. We can eventually embrace a future that looks different from the one we imagined without pretending that the original future did not matter to us.

Reproductive grief can also change the relationship we have with our bodies. Before reproductive health becomes complicated, many of us may never recognize how much trust we place in them. We assume our bodies will do certain things when we ask them to, often without consciously realizing we have made that assumption. But after a diagnosis, infertility, pregnancy loss, pain, treatment, or another reproductive experience, the body can begin to feel less like something we simply inhabit and more like something we have to monitor. Cycles become dates on calendars. Hormones become numbers. Sex can become scheduled. Symptoms are tracked. Pregnancy tests become loaded with meaning. Medical appointments begin organizing weeks and months of our lives.

For some people, then, the grief is not only about whether they will become a parent. It can also be grief for the relationship they once had with their own body, for a time when they did not have to think this hard about something that once felt as though it should simply belong to them.

This is why reproductive grief deserves to be held not only in medical spaces, but in the therapy room as well. Therapy can offer space to move beyond “What are our options?” or “What happens next?” and explore what this experience actually means. What has changed in the way you see yourself, your body, or your relationship? What are you actually grieving? Reproductive grief can be grief for certainty, identity, choice, time, trust in our bodies, a shared future, or the person we thought we would become. Our reproductive stories may be rewritten by loss, choice, illness, timing, relationships, or circumstances beyond our control, but a story changing does not make the chapters we imagined any less meaningful. Perhaps healing begins by honoring those chapters, allowing ourselves to grieve them, and remembering that grieving the future we imagined does not mean giving up on what may still lie ahead, but rather making room for the story that has yet to be written. 

Kayla Karmis, M.A.

Kayla Karmis is a doctoral clinician currently completing advanced clinical training at CORE. She is a fourth-year PsyD student in the Clinical Psychology program at the Illinois School of Professional Psychology at National Louis University. Kayla holds a Master’s degree in Clinical Psychology from the Illinois School of Professional Psychology and earned her Bachelor’s degrees in Psychology, Public Health, and Education.

Kayla has trained in a variety of clinical settings and works with adolescents and adults presenting with a wide range of concerns. She previously completed a comprehensive diagnostic assessment practicum where she conducted psychological and neuropsychological evaluations across the lifespan, administering cognitive, executive functioning, academic, personality, and socio-emotional assessment batteries. She recently completed a therapy practicum at DePaul University Counseling and Psychological Services, where she provides individual psychotherapy to college students navigating concerns related to anxiety, depression, trauma, identity development, interpersonal relationships, and life transitions.

Kayla approaches therapy from an integrative and relational framework, drawing from psychodynamic, attachment-based, and cognitive-behavioral perspectives. She believes psychological wellbeing is shaped by the interaction of biological, psychological, and social factors and values creating a collaborative, compassionate, and nonjudgmental therapeutic space where clients feel supported in exploring their experiences. Her clinical interests include trauma, emotional regulation, identity development, and the connection between physical and mental health, with a particular interest in health psychology and the ways chronic health conditions intersect with emotional wellbeing.

Next
Next

More Than a Game: What Football Has Taught Me About Family